Cecil Newry
English 301–06
Formal Argumentative Essay
Family Island Life vs. New Providence, City Life
Imagine living amongst vast, lush vegetation. Imagine being able to take advantage and to appreciate the quietude of your surroundings, the simplicity of nature. Imagine having your own private beach that you can run naked along, and skinny-dip if you wished, within the beautiful, tranquil, blue-green waters. Imagine a place where the people are inviting, accommodating and friendly. And imagine a culture where being relaxed, laid back and stressed free is the order of the day. Sounds good doesn’t it? Definitely at first glace; however, are these physical attributes attractive enough to entice the recent high school or college graduate? Can the slow, peaceful and tranquil lifestyle of the family of islands lure him/her away from the hustle and bustle of New Providence? The answer to that is simple: no! For the island of New Providence with its glamour and glitz of a modern city, is the entertainment Mecca for The Bahamas, a characteristic that most young individuals seek out to be apart of. Moreover, New Providence is the educational capital of The Bahamas, hosting the major campuses of the College of The Bahamas, (the foremost tertiary educational institution), not to mention several other post secondary institutions. Then there are the exorbitant cost of living expenses of the Family Islands in contrasts to New Providence, not even considering the fact that New Providence apparently has all the jobs, jobs, and more jobs. In deed, these simple truths prove that it is undeniably far beneficial for young adults to live on the island of New Providence in contrast to any other Family Island.
Now, everyone knows that New Providence is the place to party. In fact, it has over six major night clubs registered in The “Bahamas 2004 Telephone Directory.” Places such as the Zoo, Waterloo and the King and Knight’s night club are internationally renowned, drawing crowds from all over the world. Likewise, the young Bahamian party animals are drawn there too, desiring to take advantage of the international and high tech flavour of the clubs, something, none of the Family Islands have yet to accomplish. Alicia Smith, a recent graduate of the College of The Bahamas who migrated to Exuma to seek employment opportunities at the Emerald Bay, Four Seasons Hotel and Resort expressed similar sentiments. “The club I been too here in Exuma, had sand for the floor. It didn’t even have any neon lights either; it was just a down home atmosphere, very island like. It was far different from what I was used to in Nassau.” Like many young adults, Smith desires to live where there is a little flavour, colour, diversity, and where life is a little more challenging in nature, however, on the Family Islands like most rural areas are less dramatic centring on the simplicity of life; consequently, Smith is having issues adjusting to the change. But, New Providence’s advantages regarding entertainment for the young adult do not stop there, for New Providence can also brag that it is home to three state of the art movie theatres and two colossal shopping malls. Both the mall and the movie theatres serve as an adequate environment for young adults to date, socialize and to congregate. In fact, countries like China according to (http://www.siamfuture.com/asiannews/asiannewstxt.asp?aid=2037) brag about the ‘professional shopping service’ that shopping malls give. Moreover the site claims that the creation of shopping malls in the major Chinese cities have resulted in “better service, lower prices and more intensive service networks.” However, the family islands sadly lag behind in this regard too, having yet to see the advantages and benefits of having these places of entertainment for social gatherings. Smith expressed her dismay regarding Exuma not having a mall or movie theatre saying, “One of the things I really miss about Nassau is the Mall of Marathon. I really miss just walking around on Saturdays window shopping and I miss the Galleria too! Now, I have to be content with reading a book.”
Truly, it is technology that separates the advances of city life, New Providence, versus rural life, the Family Islands. In fact, ‘according to sociologist Saskia Sassen, the modern city is the hub of the modern technological elite who connect into high-speed private telecommunications networks while those living in the country wait and wait for things to download,’ (http://www.gerrymcgovern.com/nt/2000/nt_2000_04_24_suburban.htm). Consequently, one may conclude that the ‘emphasis of technology developers for rural areas has been on catering for needs (with small improvement) rather than creating a demand. History shows that technological development has been fuelled by creation of demand,’ (http://pune.sancharnet.in/nariphaltan/capart.htm).
Now, we must consider the educational advantages of living on New Providence in contrasts to living on a Family Island. According to Locksley Forbes in his thesis entitled the “Investigation into the Career Aspirations of Grade 12 Students in Government Schools in New Providence and the Family Islands,” students in the Family Islands top career choices consist of nursing, policing, computer programming and accounting. Through his finding it can be safe to assume that these students will be migrating to New Providence in order to fulfil their individual goals, especially since the Police College, the School for Nursing and the School of Business (housed by COB) are located on the island of New Providence; truly tough luck to say the least for students who desired to study on their native island. Sadly, it is indeed a fact that the Family Islands of the Bahamas lack the facilities to assist in the continued access to the education and training needed by Bahamians to develop their interest and capabilities to the fullest extent. In fact, this lack of facilities is associated with all rural areas as expressed in a School Issue article entitled ‘New Report Highlights the State of Rural Schools.’ The report found that rural schools have issues with:
- Recruitment and retention of rural teachers, principals, and administrators is difficult.
- Teacher salaries are lower.
- Bus rides are longer and transportation costs are higher.
- Teachers are expected to teach both in and out of the field.
- Internet access is delayed.
- Per pupil costs are higher yet levels of discretionary spending are lower.
Surely, we all would agree that a recent high school/college graduate usually never has any money on their person; his/her life is based on a constant budget. Consequently, living on a Family Island would deplete their already small resources. In fact, Smith voiced her concerns regarding this too during her interview, ‘A conch snack here does cost you ten dollars. You know they wrong for that. How’s a girl supposed to feed herself with such prices?” But, her drama does not stop there; there aren’t any fast food restaurants on any of the Family Islands, subsequently taking advantage of that quick, cheap number one or two special is an impossible. There are great benefits that comes along with the existence of fast food restaurants, “fussy eaters are guaranteed to finish a low-cost meal and parents are rewarded with a break from cooking as well as rare expressions of gratitude from their kids,” (http://recipestoday.com/resources/articles/fastfood.htm). Moreover, that due to a small economy of scale on the Family of Islands, basic products, such as household items, clothes and luxury items are twice the price when contrasted to prices on Nassau, New Providence. Amazingly, it seems as if one would have to have two to three jobs in order to maintain a standard Nassau type of living on a Family Island.
But what about the jobs, aren’t there jobs on the Family islands? Sure, if you desire to fish or farm. Alas, even with the recent economic growth on the Family Islands, islanders still migrate to the capital, New Providence, in search for employment opportunities. “The primary reason for urban migration has long been understood as the desire for higher wages or the greater expectation of employment,” (http://www.unfpa.org/swp/1996/ch4.htm). The Minister of Works Bradley Roberts in a Guardian article entitled “Family Islands to Lure Investors,” stated that “The Bahamas is set to develop infrastructure on various Family Islands in an effort to lure foreign investment and boost the tourism economy.” In fact the Minister acknowledged that it is possible that many “investors are not susceptible to invest in various Family Islands which have great economic potential for The Bahamas because of their minimal infrastructural position,” Here, we can see that due to the current limited development on the Family Islands, there will be limited career options for graduates; consequently, New Providence is clearly their better bet.
Nevertheless, not everyone would prefer to live on the island of New Providence, Jack Colebrook, a migrant from Cat Island said, “man I miss that island life style. I could leave my door open all night and sleep, and no one would ever disturb me.” “The suburban experience has at its heart a quest for privacy — a collective wish for a private life — and a quiet place,” (http://www.simonpure.com/suburbia04.htm).
Other detractors may cry out that at least the Family Islands has minimal crime when contrasted to New Providence. That may be true, but crime and deviant behaviour usually accompanies city life and with the development and the increased movement of people happening around our islands now days, such vices will spread throughout the entire Bahamas. In fact this theory was tested by the Manhattan Institute, NYC who reported based on data gained from high school students from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health, “suburban public high school students have sex, drink, smoke, use illegal drugs, and engage in delinquent behaviour as often as urban public high school students,” (http://www.citymayors.com/society/urban_teens.html). Some suburbs are beginning to experience problems historically associated with urban ills, prompting residents to move to towns farther out in the country, (http://www.simonpure.com/suburbia04.htm). Here we see that crime is relative, as no matter where one lives, there will always be negative forces effecting the youth.
Also, there are those who would remind us that the Family Islands host our exotic culture and that it maintains that, which is truly considered as being “Bahamian.” These persons would profess that New Providence is also too Americanized; moreover despite the fact that the Family Islands may not have the luxuries of the city life, there are always regattas and the sort that lure persons including young adults from the capital in order to experience that ‘down home island life.’ But truthfully how often does a regatta happen on a particular Family Island? Maybe once or twice a year, certainly that isn’t enough to quench a young adult’s thirst for excitement, for right after the regatta is completed, the mail boats are again loaded with graduates returning home in order to experience New Providence’s ‘down home’ flavour, right down at the Fish Fry! The Fish Fry may be considered the Bahamas’ premiere tourist and cultural spot.
In addition, proponents for living on the Family Islands may also put forward that Island life has a more relaxed atmosphere and lacks the ‘rat race’ that New Providence appears to have. They conclude that due to the small close knitted communities, family life is better appreciated in contrast to living on the island of New Providence. There are many who would proclaim that ‘everyone knows everyone’ in each settlement and that it is this community life that makes the Family Island so spectacular. In fact, Colebrook in his interview also suggested that the Family Island life is much better than New Providence because, “The Family Islands are cleaner; there are no traffic jams, no stresses and you are able to appreciate your surroundings more. Even the stars seem bigger and brighter on the Family Islands.” However, Adelaide and Gambier Village on New Providence has equally the same type of atmosphere, consequently, one must conclude that it is obvious that living on the island of New Providence is far better when contrasts to the Family of Islands as New Providence matches the advantages of living on the Family Islands and definitely outshines whatever the Family Islands can offer.
In conclusion, recent graduates from colleges and high schools would without doubt decide to live on the island of New Providence in contrast to living on any Family Island simply because New Providence has more to offer them. A typical young adult’s life is at a fast pace where there is a constant need to experience life to its fullest and to take advantage of its various opportunities; subsequently, it appears that currently only New Providence can offer them that growth and personal development. Clearly, when contrasted to the Family Islands, New Providence matches and surpasses the other islands with ease. New Providence has the serene atmosphere in several of his constituencies, it also has the cultural flavour and the opportunities and advantages of city life; therefore without doubt, it is undeniably far beneficial for young adults to live on the island of New Providence in contrast to any other Family Island.
Works Cited
Asofsky, Karen. Food Frenzy: Making the Most of Drive-Thru Dinners.
http://recipestoday.com/resources/articles/fastfood.htm 1999-2003 April 7, 2004
The Bahamas 2004 Telephone Directory: Bahamas: 2003.
Colebrook, Jack, Personal Interview March 11th 2004.
Forbes, Locksley. Investigation into the Career Aspirations of Grade 12 Students in
Government Schools in New Providence and the Family Islands.
Bahamas: UWI/COB UP 1976.
New Report Highlights the State of Rural Schools. http://www.educationworld.com/a_issues/issues118.shtml
Perkins, Broderick. “People Who Choose to Live in San Jose’s Downtown Have More to
Shop for Than Retail.” Silicon Valley/San Jose Business Journal Feb 14, 2003. Apr 7, 2004. http://sanjose.bizjournals.com/sanjose/stories/2003/02/17/focus1.html.
Rajvanshi, Anil. “Development of Technologies for Rural Areas—Need for New
Thinking.” Moving Technology Vol. 7, No. 1 pg. 2-5 Mar 1992 April 7, 2004
http://pune.sancharnet.in/nariphaltan/capart.htm
Rolle, Vanessa. “Family Islands to Lure Investors.” Nassau Guardian Bahamas:
November 11, 2002
Smith, Alicia, Personal (Telephone) Interview March 12th 2004.
Sadik, Nafis “Sources of city Growth UNFPA State of World Population1996 Changing
Places: Population, development and urban future.” The State of World Population 1996 Report http://www.unfpa.org/swp/1996/ch4.htm 1996 April 7, 2004.